Ref Watch: Gabriel 'very lucky' not to be sent off for Haaland clash in fiery Manchester derby

The flashpoint moment that defined Manchester City's pivotal 2-1 victory over Arsenal at the Etihad Stadium has ignited fierce debate after former referees universally agreed that Gabriel was fortunate to avoid dismissal for his challenge on Erling Haaland.

Watch the highlights: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zlTtc5ANU4U

The incident occurred in the 68th minute when Gabriel, under no apparent pressure, appeared to lead with his elbow in a challenge for the ball with Haaland. The Norwegian striker went down holding his face, and replays showed clear contact that left many pundits and referees incredulous that the Brazilian was not shown a straight red card.

Former Premier League referee Peter Mikkelsen was among those astonished by the officials' decision. "I've looked at this repeatedly, and I simply cannot understand how this wasn't a red card," Mikkelsen said. "Gabriel clearly led with his elbow, made direct contact with Haaland's face, and showed no attempt to play the ball. By the letter of the law, this is violent conduct. The fact that Haaland didn't stay down and the game continued is irrelevant to the referee's decision-making in the moment."

Match official Simon Hooper, who was in charge of the game, opted to only book Gabriel, a decision that has drawn severe criticism from former players and managers across the footballing world. The incident occurred in a crucial phase of the match, with the score level at 1-1 and both teams pushing for a winner that could define the title race.

Former Arsenal defender Martin Keown was particularly scathing. "Gabriel should have been walking," Keown stated. "This is exactly the kind of challenge that the VAR was brought in to correct. The on-field referee may have missed it, but the VAR should have intervened. Haaland was fortunate not to be seriously injured."

The Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) is expected to release a statement addressing the incident, though such statements rarely criticise officials directly. Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta declined to comment on the specific incident, while Pep Guardiola expressed relief that Haaland was able to continue.

The debate has reignited discussions about the consistency of officiating standards and whether current guidelines adequately protect players from dangerous challenges. With the title race reaching its climax, this decision could have lasting implications for the destination of the Premier League trophy.